9 Takeaways from “Speak Up or Stay Silent? Navigating Crisis Communication in the New Organization Statement Era”

In today’s climate of constant scrutiny and rapid response, association and nonprofit communicators continue to face the complex challenge of knowing when to speak — and what to say — when crises or social issues arise. During her PRSA Association/Nonprofit Conference session on October 27, 2025, Vanguard Vice President and Community-Driven Communications Practice Lead Crystal Borde guided communicators through these high-stakes moments of decision, sharing how to ensure that every message reflects an organization’s mission, values and long-term trust with its communities. Attendees gained practical strategies and frameworks for crafting statements that resonate authentically and align with their organization’s purpose, even under pressure.

In today’s polarized environment, association and nonprofit communicators are under increasing pressure to respond publicly to fast-moving crises and social issues — from Supreme Court decisions to protests, wars and executive orders. Knowing when to speak out and how to do it authentically has never been more complex. 

During my PRSA Association/Nonprofit Conference session, “Speak Up or Stay Silent? Crisis Communication in the New Organization Statement Era,” I explored how organizations can decide whether to comment publicly, how to craft statements that reflect their mission and values, and how to mitigate backlash when they do. 

Here are nine key takeaways for communicators navigating this era of constant scrutiny. 

  1. Recognize the “New Organization Statement Era.” We are living in a time when stakeholders expect — and sometimes demand — that organizations take a public stand on social, cultural and political issues. This era began with events like George Floyd’s murder and continued through the pandemic, the January 6th insurrection, Supreme Court rulings and global conflicts. Each moment tests whether our organizations can respond with clarity, compassion and credibility.
  2. Remember: Just because we can say something doesn’t mean we should. Before reacting, pause and ask the critical question: Does speaking out serve our mission, our stakeholders and our credibility — or just our impulse to respond? In crisis communications, discernment is as powerful as speed.
  3. Understand that both silence and speech carry risk. Speaking out can make you appear performative or alienate stakeholders who disagree. Staying silent can create perceptions of complicity or indifference. Silence is also a message — and if you choose it, make sure it’s strategic, not fearful.
  4. Use a framework for decision-making. Before issuing a statement, evaluate your readiness through four essential questions. If you answer “no” to more than one, it might not be your organization’s moment to lead publicly:
    • Does this align with our mission and values? 
    • Are our stakeholders directly impacted? 
    • Do we have credibility or history in this space? 
    • Can we follow our words with action? 
  1. Know when speaking up is strategic — and when silence is. Speak up when the issue affects your mission, your stakeholders or an area where your organization has long-standing expertise or leadership. Stay silent (for now) when others are better positioned to lead, when your internal actions speak louder than public words or when you can’t yet back up your statement with concrete steps.
  2. Avoid the pitfalls that erode trust. In the rush to respond, many statements fall flat because they sound generic or detached. Phrases like “we stand in solidarity” without specifics or “mistakes were made” without accountability undermine trust. Avoid copy-paste templates, false equivalence (“both sides”) and vague sentiments that lack purpose or empathy.
  3. Craft values-driven statements. When you do speak, make every word count. Be specific about the issue and why it matters. Echo your organization’s mission and values. Center impacted communities and offer tangible actions. Use inclusive, plain and human language. Invite collaboration or dialogue when appropriate.
  4. Prepare for impact — inside and out. Before publishing, loop in HR, Legal, and Employee Resource Groups. Anticipate backlash. Equip staff with talking points and listening tools. Afterward, monitor social media and media responses and be ready to update or clarify. Transparency and accountability are essential for long-term credibility.
  5. Redefine success: It’s not about making a statement. It’s about making a difference. The real question isn’t “Should we say something?” — it’s “Can we say and do something that makes a difference?” The best communications are authentic, timely, and tied to a mission and values. They don’t chase headlines — they strengthen trust.

In the “New Organization Statement Era,” communicators are more than messengers — we are stewards of credibility. Our decisions to speak up or stay silent shape not only how others see our organizations, but how deeply our missions resonate in moments that matter most.